Black Friday Shopping Psychology: Are You Being Manipulated?
Black Friday shopping psychology explained: fake discounts, FOMO, beauty marketing, buy now, pay later and the tricks retailers use to make us overspend.
MONEY & WORKCULTURE
David Chen
11/21/20267 min read
Black Friday is back. The discounts are bigger, the countdown clocks are ticking, your favourite influencer has a discount code, and somehow everything you never knew you needed is suddenly 40% off. But how much of this shopping is actually saving you money?
Let's play a little game.
You open Instagram to check one message. Fifteen minutes later, you're watching a woman explain why you absolutely need a new skincare routine, a particular handbag and a kitchen gadget that makes your life 10 times easier.
Then you see it.
BLACK FRIDAY. UP TO 70% OFF. ENDS TONIGHT.
You weren't planning to buy anything. But now you're comparing prices, checking reviews and calculating how much you're saving.
Except you're not saving $80. You're spending $120.
Welcome to the psychology of Black Friday.
And there's a surprisingly clever business strategy behind why it works.
How did Black Friday become a shopping obsession?
Black Friday has an interesting history.
The first recorded use of the phrase dates back to September 1869, when a US gold-market crash devastated investors.
Its connection to shopping came much later. During the 1950s and 1960s, Philadelphia police used the term to describe the crowds, traffic and chaos that followed Thanksgiving.
Retailers eventually gave the phrase a more positive explanation: the day stores moved from operating in the red (losses) to being in the black (profits).
By the 1980s, Black Friday had become a major retail event. Then came online shopping, and Cyber Monday emerged in the 2000s as its digital counterpart.
Today, it's no longer a single day. Retailers stretch promotions across November, creating what is practically an entire month of shopping.
In 2026, Black Friday falls on November 27, followed by Cyber Monday on November 30.
And the business behind it? Enormous.
Black Friday shopping psychology: your brain loves a bargain
Here's the first psychological trick: anchoring.
Imagine seeing a handbag originally priced at $200, now available for $100.
Your brain compares the two numbers and registers a $100 saving.
But what if the handbag was rarely sold for $200 in the first place?
The original price becomes an anchor. Instead of asking whether the product is worth $100, you start thinking about how much you're saving.
That's why a discount can feel like a reward even when the final price isn't particularly attractive.
FOMO marketing and the imaginary deadline
Then there's FOMO, or the fear of missing out.
Only two left. Sale ends in 15 minutes. 23 people are viewing this product.
Suddenly, you're not making a purchase decision. You're racing against an imaginary deadline.
Research published in the Journal of Promotion Management found that limited-time promotional messages can encourage impulse purchases, with fear of missing out playing an important role.
Your brain starts prioritising the possibility of losing a deal over whether you actually need the product.
Fake Black Friday discounts are a real problem
Not every discount is dishonest. But not every advertised discount is what it appears to be either.
Some retailers inflate reference prices, advertise products at misleading original prices or create artificial urgency around promotions.
The US Federal Trade Commission has identified these tactics as examples of deceptive online design, often called dark patterns.
These include fake countdown timers, misleading limited-time messages, hidden charges and confusing checkout processes.
A 2026 Boston Consulting Group study of more than 10,000 consumers in ten countries found that only 54% trusted advertised prices during major shopping events, while one in five actively distrusted them. Real-time scarcity messages, the "only two left" kind, were among the least trusted signals in the survey.
That's quite a trust problem for an industry built around convincing people they're getting a great deal.
The simple fix? Check the actual price history, compare retailers and don't treat a crossed-out price as proof of savings.
The buy now, pay later trap
This is where things get particularly interesting.
Buy Now, Pay Later (BNPL) services allow customers to split purchases into smaller instalments, often with no interest if payments are made on time.
Sounds convenient.
But there's a psychological difference between seeing a $200 purchase and seeing four payments of $50.
The second feels much more affordable, even though you're still spending $200.
And when you're buying five different things through five different payment plans, those smaller amounts can quietly pile up.
The US Consumer Financial Protection Bureau has highlighted risks including overextension, automatic repayment requirements and the use of consumer data to encourage additional purchases.
A December 2025 CFPB report also found sharp increases in BNPL purchasing volume around the holiday season.
The problem isn't necessarily instalment payments themselves. It's losing track of how much you owe.
A purchase doesn't become cheaper because you've divided the bill into four pieces.
Beauty advertising: why are women constantly being sold a better version of themselves?
Let's talk about beauty and lifestyle marketing.
Women are constantly being shown products that promise to improve something about them.
A better skincare routine. Better hair. Better clothes. A better body. A more organised home. A more put-together life.
And Black Friday gives brands the perfect opportunity to package all those promises into a shopping event.
There's a reason beauty brands invest so heavily in influencer marketing, tutorials, reviews and personalised product recommendations.
A 2025 Tinuiti beauty marketing study found that nearly two-thirds of surveyed beauty shoppers had purchased a beauty product based on an influencer's recommendation in the previous year. Among Gen Z beauty shoppers, the figure was 90%.
A systematic review published in Frontiers in Psychology in 2025, analysing 95 peer-reviewed studies, also found associations between idealised advertising portrayals and negative outcomes for women's body image and self-perception.
Think about the message behind some beauty advertisements.
You don't just need a moisturiser. You need to fix your skin barrier.
You don't just need shampoo. You need to rescue your damaged hair.
You don't just need clothes. You need a new wardrobe because your current one apparently isn't giving.
There's nothing wrong with enjoying beauty products or fashion. But when advertising repeatedly makes women feel that something about them needs fixing, shopping becomes more than shopping.
It becomes an attempt to buy confidence.
And confidence is a rather profitable thing to sell.
Social media has turned shopping into entertainment
Black Friday used to mean newspaper advertisements, shopping lists and queues outside stores.
Now it means TikTok hauls, Instagram links, livestream shopping and creators showing you what they bought before you've even finished your morning coffee.
TikTok reported that #holidayshopping content increased 263% in September 2026 compared with August.
Its 2026 Black Friday and Cyber Monday campaign, running on TikTok Shop from November 11 to 30, also leans on livestreams, creator recommendations and in-app shopping experiences.
The interesting part is that people aren't always opening social media with the intention of buying something.
They discover products while scrolling.
A skincare review becomes a product search. A celebrity outfit becomes a shopping link. A home organisation video becomes a cart full of storage boxes.
The distinction between entertainment and advertising gets blurry.
And sometimes the person influencing your purchase is someone whose lifestyle you admire, not a traditional salesperson.
Is Black Friday actually worth it?
Absolutely, sometimes.
If you've been planning to replace your laptop, buy a household appliance or purchase something you genuinely need, a verified discount can save you money.
The problem is buying something simply because it's cheaper today.
PwC's Holiday Outlook 2026 found that eight in ten surveyed US consumers planned to use a budgeting strategy for the holiday season, while 79% said deals and discounts influenced when they shopped.
That's a useful reminder: shoppers are interested in saving, but they're also becoming more conscious of their spending.
And retailers are responding with personalised deals, AI-powered recommendations and increasingly sophisticated shopping experiences.
The same BCG study found that around 56% of consumers planned to use AI tools for their sales-season shopping in 2026, up eight points from the previous year.
So the future may involve asking an AI tool to compare prices instead of trusting the giant red SALE banner.
How to shop Black Friday and Cyber Monday deals without falling for the psychology
Before checking out, ask yourself three things:
Would I buy this if it weren't discounted?
Have I checked whether the original price is genuine?
Can I comfortably afford the full amount without relying on instalments?
And give yourself a little time before making non-essential purchases.
A deal that disappears because you took an hour to think about it probably wasn't worth your financial peace anyway.
The bottom line
Black Friday isn't going anywhere. Neither is advertising, influencer marketing or the desire to treat ourselves.
But it's worth recognising that the shopping experience is designed to influence how we think, feel and spend.
The retailers understand urgency. They understand FOMO. They understand how a $50 instalment feels different from a $200 bill.
And they understand that selling someone the feeling of getting a bargain can be just as powerful as selling the product itself.
So, by all means, enjoy the sales.
Buy the lipstick. Get the headphones. Replace the washing machine.
Just don't let a countdown clock decide what happens to your money.
Because getting 40% off something you didn't need isn't saving 40%. It's spending money with better marketing.
At Femonomic, we believe financial independence starts with understanding not just what we're buying, but why we're buying it.
Sources
History: What's the real history of Black Friday?
Federal Trade Commission: Bringing Dark Patterns to Light
Boston Consulting Group: For Year-End Sales Events, Trust Is the New Currency (November 2026)
Consumer Financial Protection Bureau: Buy Now, Pay Later, Market Trends and Consumer Impacts
Consumer Financial Protection Bureau: The Buy Now, Pay Later Market (December 2025)
Journal of Promotion Management: Limited-time messages, FOMO and impulse purchases
Tinuiti: 2025 Beauty Marketing Study
TikTok Newsroom: What's shaping the holiday season on TikTok Shop (October 2026)
Work with us
